Racist Cape Town (redux)

white_area

Note: Those who have already read my earlier post on this subject might want to skip this column, as there is a significant overlap in content (around 90%). The text below represents an attempt to make my key concerns more evident, and is the version submitted to The Daily Maverick for my column this week.

A few weeks ago, my (occasional) fellow Opinionista Victor Dlamini Tweeted a link to an IOL report describing an instance of apparent racial profiling at the V&A Waterfront in Cape Town. The conversation which resulted should surprise no one at all, in that it consisted of the usual mix of protestation from Capetonians eager to refute the notion of Cape Town being a racist city, alongside various endorsements and examples of such racism.

Now that the local government elections campaigns are behind us, it is perhaps possible to discuss this issue more productively. Whether Cape Town fits the stereotype or not, it’s useful for the ANC to perpetuate the stereotype of Capetonian racism, as they enthusiastically did in the matter of Makhaza, as well as on several other occasions, however slight the opportunity to do so actually was. Well, they at least thought it useful – the election results could well indicate a greater agnosticism on this issue. But the politicisation of the issue tends to polarise opinion, rather than clarify the issue.

So, one could start by pointing out that to say that Cape Town is a racist city does not mean that everyone in Cape Town is racist. It certainly does not mean, as ANC spokesperson Jackson Mthembu alleges, that the governing party of Cape Town and the Western Cape is racist. I don’t believe that they are, and I also don’t agree with interpretations of events like the Makhaza toilet case which are used to support this claim.

Furthermore, it’s also perfectly understandable that the DA would protest claims that Cape Town is inherently racist – pointing to the diversity in the party, service-delivery successes, and Cape Town’s relatively low (compared to the other metro’s) Gini coefficient. Lastly, it could be expected that many white liberal sorts (such as myself) would feel offence as a result of such claims. But as I’ve frequently argued, offence is no guide to the truth, and also shouldn’t be used to drown out noises you don’t like hearing.

While it is of course true that there are racists everywhere, this doesn’t preclude the possibility of Cape Town containing a higher proportion of them, or for some Capetonians to be in denial as to how enlightened they actually are. If so, then it would make sense to say that Cape Town is ‘a racist city’, by comparison to other relevant South African cities.

And of course there are cities that are more racist than Cape Town – Orania would be a possible example. But despite all these disclaimers and qualifications, when compared with our other capitals or other major cities in South Africa, we certainly hear more stories about racist encounters or instances of perceived racism emanating from Cape Town.

Perceptions are not always true. Stereotypes can be perpetuated, sometimes through evidence, and sometimes through prejudice. It’s possible, for example, that the trope of a racist Cape Town is a simple consequence of jealousy, in that Northerners (and the ANC) want to find fault in what seems – on the surface at least, and also to many of those who live here – to be the best place in South Africa to call home.

I can understand the anger of those who claim the stereotype of a racist Cape Town to be founded on prejudice, but I’m afraid I’m reluctant to agree with them. We shouldn’t forget that Cape Town’s urban planning was intentionally premised on the maintenance of social order, which in those days meant segregation of the races. Numerous books and papers detail the history of the City as divided on racial lines, such as this paper from Charlotte Spinks at the London School of Economics (pdf). In addition to academic texts, we have semi-regular accounts of discrimination at certain bars and clubs, and first-hand experiences of racism like those described in Xhanti Payi’s column, published last year in The Daily Maverick.

Anecdotal accounts of racism in Cape Town abound, but anecdotes are of course not data. The problem, though, is that we hear far fewer such anecdotes from other cities. And more than anecdotes, existing research such as the Surtee and Hall report (pdf) also appear to corroborate claims regarding racism in Cape Town.

And while some critics (including the DA) reject the findings of that report, one could argue that Helen Zille’s response doesn’t properly address the possibility of racism directed at black South Africans, in that it’s largely focused on the facts of integration and equity in the coloured population (I use this term as per Employment Equity legislation, rather than because I think they are sensible).

Two entirely separate issues could be co-existing here, and should not be conflated: First, it’s entirely possible – even probable – that the ANC uses the ‘racist Cape Town’ card as a political weapon against the DA, and in doing so might exaggerate the extent to which racism is prevalent in Cape Town. But second, it is also possible that black visitors to (and residents of) Cape Town experience racist treatment exceeding the levels found in other parts of the country. We shouldn’t pretend that this possibility doesn’t exist, simply because we don’t like it.

Cape Town does have a higher proportion of whites and coloureds than the other metros. And if racists are everywhere, we could well have more of them here than, for example, in Johannesburg. The facts of this matter could easily be established via a proper survey of attitudes and behaviours across the country, if we cared to do so. Until we do, anecdotes and perceptions are all we have – and the perceptions are real, and no doubt hurtful, to those who have them.

In other words, if it is the case that Cape Town is perceived as being racist, this perception is a problem in itself, regardless of the truth of the allegations themselves. And my opinion – right or wrong – is that this perception is grounded in reality. But whether it’s mere perception or not, we’re not going to fix whatever problems do exist – whether racism or the perception thereof – by being offended, or by insulting those who make such claims.

Defensive reactions such as these forestall debate. And whether prejudice exists equally everywhere or not, we know it at least exists everywhere. Perhaps, then, the real lesson lies in what Sipho Hlongwane Tweeted at the time, “CPT and JHB are often equally prejudiced. Only one city is honest & confronts this”.

Let’s start by making that two cities, and then not stop there.

  • brian

    Interesting piece. As a born an bred Joburger who spent a lot of time in Cape Town as a youngster and then later after my parents moved there, I can say that I don’t believe that cape Town is any more racist than Johannesburg. having said that, however, I must add the caveat that I believe Capetonians – by which I mean people who were born and bred there and have not really lived anywhere else – to be extremely insular. I recall an email conversation with a Capetonian lady back when I was playing the dating game. It went something like this:
    Me: I find Cape Town to be an unfriendly place.
    Her: Rubbish. It’s the friendliest city in the country.
    Me: Really? So tell me, how many of your personal friends were born somewhere other than Cape Town?
    Her: None…
    Chalk that up as another anecdote.

  • Tim

    As a black Jozi South African who went to varsity in Cape Town and lived in CPT, I think it is more fact than anything else that Cape Town is EXTREMELY racist. Even worse is the black on black discrimination there. The denial of this is the problem.

    Factors such as how few cape townians have travelled in South Africa and the socio economic split or acceptance by Capetownians to stay within the apartheid demographics are key. Blacks and coloured people still live in the “townships” / “Cape Flat lands” and they are comfortable with that without developing their areas or moving to the surburbs.

    Look at SOWETO. Wow, people are aspiring and moving to Sandton and those in the hood are making it a better place.

    I could not believe having an argument with a Capetownian who argued the demographics of the country, actually really thinking the SA Black/white ratio is 50/50.

    What absolute ignorance in that City

  • Neal

    It’s certainly an interesting view and one where I also hope to be untrue. As you mentioned, it’s the one metro where there is a high density of white and coloured people, but I wonder what the reverse is like in other metros. I often think that some white people are effected by racism but are unsure how to take it or report it as it might not go further, or something I’m less able to put into words. But maybe it goes along with your denial comment. I generally stay clear of policial debate, especially around radical, but I love Cape Town and love any integration that happens here.

    I grew up in Botswana, and any racial tension caused was normally caused by South African expats living there, which is sad. I think South Africa has so much to learn, but the constant bitterness, and possible greed, is stopping this from happening and moving forward.

  • Ke Soabile

    Well, here in Capetown, there are places where in a non-white person visits, one feels that he/she is not wanted at all.

    You see, my parents moved us (their children) out of South Africa at a very young age and we have seen racism on all sorts of media, but we never got affected directly like many South Africans. We see every person as unique as he/she deserves regardless of colour, greed, etc.

    Now at my age (52 years) this things caught yesterday (12.02. 2012) at London Town Pub al Koeberg Road in Cape Town at around 14:30.

    I visited this place LONDON TOWN PUB to have lunch and listening to live music. I ordrered my beer and food and I was seated at a table for four. Well I could have sat at the bar counter but I wanted to have my meal on a proper table and it was not reserved, so I took it my meal and my got served no problem.

    While I was still seated eating and drinking a lady working there put two tags written “Reserved” on the very table I was using. I didn’t mind and only thought it is reserved for me.

    I ordrered another Castle Draught no problem and I paid; as usual. Then thereafter I was told to leave that table as it was “Reserved”. I made a small quarrel: saying why did the reserve a table while I was still it?

    But I headed to the counter to have with my beer; but the guys who the table was reserved, said to me I should not leave that table but to stay with which.

    Then the Big Manager call to a corner and said I should leave that table and I related what has happened and why I did not leave that table an we parted. After two minutes he (Big Manager) came back with R20.00 (Twenty Rands) and took my beer and ordered me to leave immediately!

    I was so surprised and I knew I had not done anything wrong and I left in peace. I don’t he stayed in peace himself because he was fuming.

    This was not the first time that he did a funny to me. On 05.02.2012, I had taken a walk to the Woodbridge Island and I came back thirsty and I wanted my cold Castle Draught. I headed to LONDON TOWN PUB. I was in my short pants and sports shoes. As I entered that Pub (something I shall do again)the very Big Manager called outside and showed me a notice that said After 6pm dress should be smart casual.

    I said sorry, I will dress that way again and he allowed me entry.

    I have never had any problem with the people who visit that place except that Big Manager.

    I am new in this area and I am learning very fast.

    May the Soul of the Big Manager rest in peace when the time has come.